Showing posts with label Reason and the Public. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reason and the Public. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 26, 2013

“Self-preservation is the great law of nature”


I wanted to look at the character of La Motte and to a lesser extent the character of the Marquis and go into detail about a few of their interactions in volume three.

                What really intrigued me were the conversations between the two characters at the abbey and the way that we can see the internal struggle of La Motte. Up until now La Motte really has been acting out of self –preservation, fleeing Paris to avoid being captured and in general looking out for number one. I really think that up to this point that La Motte has not shown many outward signs of remorse from self- reflection. It seems that Radcliffe has done this just to make La Motte’s epiphany that much greater when he does begin to reflect on what he has done. The catalyst for this reflection is the Marquis, who is a man of greater means both financially and socially and his request that La Motte kill Adeline. This of course causes La Motte to panic since he had grown fond of Adeline and had no desire to kill her.  The perfect summation of the moment of realization is right at the beginning of chapter 15 “He saw himself entangled in the web which his own crimes had woven.” Being in the power of the Marquis, he knew he must either consent to the commission of a deed, from the enormity of which, depraved as he was, he shrunk in horror, or sacrifice fortune, freedom, probably life itself, to the refusal.”

                I do not believe this revelation would have occurred if the request had not come from a socially equal or inferior person. Since it was the Marquis who asked for the death of Adeline, La Motte had to at least consider the consequences of A. what was being asked and B. what the repercussions were for refusing to do so would be. I believe it was because of the Marquis that we are able to see a shift in the character of La Motte from just acting out of self- preservation to looking to the safety of others.

Tuesday, February 12, 2013

A portrait of Dealing with Death


I find that in his poem “We Are Seven” Wordsworth really does something unique with his writing and that is give a glimpse into how a poor young girl sees the world. In the conversation between the man and the young girl we learn that there are seven children total, it becomes very quickly understood that not all is as it seems. She says there are seven but two dead and four are gone away. This strikes me on a number of levels. The first is because it was not uncommon for non- aristocratic families to have large numbers of kids and depending on their social status or income may not have been able to care for all of them on their own and for Wordsworth to make a reference to this seems a bit odd. The second reason is even though her two siblings are gone she still counts them as among us as if nothing had happened. I cannot pretend to know what Wordsworth vision for the cultural sentiment towards the dead in this poem would be. Reading this made me more curious as to what his views on the place of the dead in his own society were and was this poem based on some of his own life experiences or was he taking in descriptions and looking at how certain groups viewed their deceased?

Tuesday, January 29, 2013

Reason and Fantasy


I was struck the contrasting themes of reason and fantasy while reading James Hogg’s “Expedition to Hell” mostly because if you read the story with these two themes in mind I believe that you get an excellent mixture of the major influencing factors the  world that James Hogg lived in. In the story Hogg mixes in some of the popular scientific queries of the day such as the delving into what a dream really is with the more fantasy driven themes like demons and literally driving oneself into hell. The best scene or I suppose dialogue in the story that I can point to is when the doctor and George’s wife are discussing the situation with George himself. The doctor and Chirsty can plainly see that something is troubling her husband yet they approach his quandary with a reason driven approach rather than George, who sees his problem as one that is of a more supernatural one than reason. In the end the wife and doctor can make a logical reason for why George died but lack a means of knowing what it was that drove him into his state in the first place. This piece is to me an excellent representation of the time, reason and fantasy were still accepted but it nears the end of  the peaceful coexistence of the two ideas.