Thursday, May 9, 2013

Boys and their Country, a Social Commentary


One of the most popular lines concerning writing would be, “write what you know.” The authors we have studied from Romanticism to the Victorian era have taken this cliché and ran with it. The authors take what is going on in their life, brood over it, and transform it into an excellent piece of literature that may or may not have a gigantic impact on their contemporary audience. Through specific examples from Cowper, Stevenson, Conrad, and Kipling, a theme of social commentary on contemporary events can be seen stretching from the literature of the 18th century to the work of the early 20th century.
The abolition of slavery came about in Great Britain rather early compared to countries such as the United States. The Slavery Abolition Act of 1833 dispelled slavery throughout the empire, except for in territories in possession of the East India Company. This Act was the final push following the Slave Trade Act of 1907, which had abolished the British Slave trade. Which of course still happened, but the 1833 act dispelled any need for the trade.  William Cowper, born in the early 18th century, belonged to the evangelist sect of the Christian Church, and was an abolitionist. The Evangelical church was well known for their part in the abolition of the slave trade, and according to Reddie in his article, The Church: Enslaver or Liberator, “But the real thrust of Christian abolitionism emerged from the evangelical revival of the 18th century, which spawned dynamic Christians who had clear-cut beliefs on morality and sin, which shaped their approach to the issue of slavery.” By being part of the Evangelical Church, Cowper was taught to be in opposition to slavery, a major contemporary event of the time. Through his poems, “The Negros’s Complaint,” and “Pity for Poor Africans,” Cowper could express his views on the issue of slavery, which due to his morals and involvement in the Evangelical Church, were pro-abolition. For the presentation on Cowper, my partner and I found a link on the British Library that allowed us to see something we didn’t expect, images from a picture book with Cowper’s poem, “Pity for Poor Africans.” We found this through the British Library Website which turned out to be an excellent source not only for reading about Cowper, but also as a place of general information about the British Abolitionist movement. http://www.bl.uk/learning/histcitizen/campaignforabolition/sources/antislavery/aspoem/negroscomplaint.html

This source also provided the fantastic images from the picture book that was based on the poem. The illustrations can also been seen as a social commentary through the medium of Cowper’s poem.


All in all, Cowper’s work addresses the contemporary issue of abolition during the 18th century. Through his works, Cowper is remembered for his place in the abolitionist movement, and his effort to help the slaves through his religion.
            Robert Lewis Stevenson’s, “The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde,” is a commentary both on industrialization and the advancement of the Sciences. The idea of Jekyll and Hyde being a reflection of industrialization came from a blog post someone posted approaching the subject. Although the industrial revolution predated the release of the novel, it could still be seen as a social commentary, especially if Stevenson was writing the novel during the industrial revolution, or even just brain storming about it. The industrial Revolution was all about change and the advancement of society through machinery and technology. One could say the same thing about Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, except the technology affecting them could also be seen through the advancement of the sciences. In a true out with the old, in with the new fashion, Dr. Jekyll transforms himself into Mr. Hyde, who is younger, stronger, more rash than Dr, Jekyll could ever be. Then again Hyde is also a monster. At first appearance Dr. Jekyll might have though that this evolution into Mr. Hyde would be a fantastic thing, who doesn’t love advancement in technology? Once Dr. Jekyll realizes that he has turned into a horrible monster the story turns to horror, and we are left feeling shaken. The same idea could be applied to the industrial revolution. Everyone thought that the Industrial Revolution would be a fantastic thing, it was idealized through art, an example being Joseph Wright of Derby’s Arkwright’s Mills by Night, where the mill is the source of light in the meadow, lighting up the surrounding area with it’s awesomeness.
 Later, it is discovered that the industrial revolution has many negative effects such as, pollution, child labor, people getting hurt, etc. Stevenson, whether intentional or not has tapped into this idea that a good idea can lead to a bad result, and he makes this social commentary through the medium of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde.

            Imperialism by Britain became and affluent idea during the late 18th century and early 19th century as Britain took claim to India and areas in Africa. The main idea of imperialism, as it had been with their earlier exploits with the thirteen colonies, was that the new areas would be used for trade. Companies such as the East India Company grew in popularity as British citizens gained access to new materials such as teas, silks, and even diamonds from a range of territories now under British rule. These places could be seen as “outposts,” because they were there primarily for the purpose of trade and the good of the British economy. Plus, it was most likely that these new British territories were giving more than they were receiving, yet again emphasizing the idea of the “outpost” that Conrad uses in his writings on imperialism. Conrad’s “Secret Sharer,” and the “Outpost of Progress,” provides a look into the social history of imperialism. Through journeys such as Captain Cook’s three voyages, people began to gain a greater understanding of the mysterious lands that Great Britain was beginning to possess. According to Bernard Smith, “Cook’s voyages were not only fact- gathering phenomena, they deeply affected conceptual thought…” (Smith). A series of images were produced during the period of imperialization, some were informational, like the works the artists, such as William Hodges, on Cook’s voyages produced, and others were more mocking, such as political cartoons.



British Imperialism was the source of inspiration for Conrad’s social commentary on the happenings of the country. Whether or not he liked it, imperialism was happening, and outposts were springing up everywhere.
Kipling’s work “Epitaphs of War,” was influenced by World War I, which happened between 1914 and 1918. The BBC provides a great overview of the political climate previous to and after World War I.  http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/british/britain_wwone/overview_britain_ww1_01.shtml.

Over 9 million soldiers were killed over all the nations that went into the war; a lot of these deaths were due to improvements in warfare technology, such as mustard gas. Other technologies were explored during World War I; one that was discussed in class would be photography. There was a presentation on photography during World War I, which was insanely interesting. Photography during war is not thought about much, which made the presentation even more informational. It was also sad how many soldiers died because they wanted to be war photographers.

These photographs would be seen in England, creating an emotional effect on the population. Photographs of the dead along with a long list of deceased soldiers name in the papers really hit home for Great Britain. These men were people’s sons, husbands, lovers, etc. and seeing this list every morning had to be the worst part of everyone’s day. Kipling chose to write epitaphs for soldiers who had died in the war. This could be seen as a social commentary based on the types of things he was saying. Certain epitaphs such as “The Coward,” could be seen as having a negative connotation towards the soldiers. Or it could be taken as a negative comment on Britain’s involvement in this war, which forced men into a situation that they might not be able to handle. Other epitaphs such as, “A Son,” identified with those mothers who lost their sons at such an early age. There was an epitaph for everyone, something for someone to identify with that might help them with the pain of losing a loved one.  Kipling’s social commentary is very overt, he’s talking about World War I, but it is hard to tell whether he is supportive of the war effort, or anti-war by reading his epitaphs. The one thing that can be readily understood is that Kipling felt that these men deserved a proper homage to be paid to them, and he did this though the epitaphs.
            Although the contemporary events of Cowper, Stevenson, Conrad, and Kipling are diverse and spread over multiple centuries, the four authors share a common bond. All of them are taking what is happening in their lives and turning it into inspiration for their work. These events might have been rough, especially in the case of World War I and Kipling, but the author’s took it with a grain of salt and got their opinions across via the medium of the written word. Social commentary by authors will probably always be a popular theme, after all, they are just writing what they know. 

Works cited:

Reddie, Richard. "The Church: Enslaver or Liberator?" BBC News. BBC, 17 Feb. 2011. Web. 09 May 2013.

Smith, Bernard. "Art as Information." Imagining the Pacific in the Wake of the Cook Voyages. New Haven and London: Yale UP, 1992. 50-76. Print.

No comments:

Post a Comment